Find the right balance between a deep or broad IA

Last updated
Save as PDF

Balancing depth and breadth in IA is key; too much depth frustrates users, while too much breadth overwhelms them. By understanding the pitfalls of both extremes and employing user-centered design principles, you can create a structure that is intuitive, efficient, and effective.

Striking the right balance between depth and breadth is crucial for creating a user-friendly experience. An overly deep structure can bury information, making it hard to find. An overly wide structure can overwhelm users with too many choices. In both scenarios your end users will quickly run into a high-effort situation which will push them to give up on navigation. This can lead to a poor user experience.

This article explores the importance of finding this balance and offers practical tips for achieving it.

IA that is too deep

When an information architecture is too deep, users have to navigate through numerous layers to find what they need. This can cause:

Increased cognitive load: Users must remember their path and make more decisions at each level.
Longer navigation time: More clicks and steps are required to reach the desired information.
Higher abandonment / bounce rates: Users are more likely to give up if they cannot find information quickly.

IA that is too wide

An overly wide structure presents the following challenges:

Decision fatigue: Users may feel overwhelmed by too many options at each level.
Difficulty scanning: It is harder to quickly scan a page and locate the desired information.
Inconsistent UX: Users may struggle to predict where information is located.

Strike the right balance

The balance between these two options is where you will find the sweet spot, an IA that users can navigate effortlessly to quickly find the information they are looking for.

If you are struggling to find a good middle ground, consider these strategies:

User-centered design: Understand your users’ needs, behaviors, and preferences. Conduct user research and usability testing to inform your structure.
Progressive disclosure: Reveal information progressively, showing only what is necessary at each stage. This reduces cognitive load and helps users focus.
Consistent naming conventions: Use clear and consistent labels for Categories, Guides, and Articles. This improves predictability and ease of navigation.
Regular reviews and updates: Continuously review and update your information architecture based on user feedback and changing needs.